Elizabeth Johnstone

Elizabeth Johnstone

Real Estate Advisor

Mystic Brokerage

41 Williams Avenue
Mystic, CT 06355

Elizabeth grew up in New York City and spent her summers in beautiful Stonington by the sea—conveniently located between NYC and Boston. After marrying attorney Philip Johnstone, she made Stonington her full-time home, raising her family in the charming Stonington Borough where they continue to reside today.

As a lifelong resident with deep roots in the community, Elizabeth brings a unique perspective to real estate. Her experience living, working, raising a family, and contributing to Stonington has given her an intimate understanding of what makes this area so special—and she's eager to share that knowledge with her clients.

Whether you're buying or selling, Elizabeth will professionally guide you through every step of the process, from contract to inspection to a successful closing. Her commitment to exceptional service and local expertise ensures you'll have a trusted advisor by your side throughout your real estate journey.

When she's not working with clients, Elizabeth enjoys swimming and walking the beautiful Rhode Island beaches. She is an active member of the Stonington Garden Club, where she has served on the board and chaired both the Community Gardens and Native Plant Committees, reflecting her dedication to preserving and enhancing the natural beauty of the community she calls home.

Elizabeth grew up in New York City and spent her summers in beautiful Stonington by the sea—conveniently located between NYC and Boston. After marrying attorney Philip Johnstone, she made Stonington her full-time home, raising her family in the charming Stonington Borough where they continue to reside today.

As a lifelong resident with deep roots in the community, Elizabeth brings a unique perspective to real estate. Her experience living, working, raising a family, and contributing to Stonington has given her an intimate understanding of what makes this area so special—and she's eager to share that knowledge with her clients.

Whether you're buying or selling, Elizabeth will professionally guide you through every step of the process, from contract to inspection to a successful closing. Her commitment to exceptional service and local expertise ensures you'll have a trusted advisor by your side throughout your real estate journey.

When she's not working with clients, Elizabeth enjoys swimming and walking the beautiful Rhode Island beaches. She is an active member of the Stonington Garden Club, where she has served on the board and chaired both the Community Gardens and Native Plant Committees, reflecting her dedication to preserving and enhancing the natural beauty of the community she calls home.

Elizabeth grew up in New York City and spent her summers in beautiful Stonington by the sea—conveniently located between NYC and Boston. After marrying attorney Philip Johnstone, she made Stonington her full-time home, raising her family in the charming Stonington Borough where they continue to reside today.

As a lifelong resident with deep roots in the community, Elizabeth brings a unique perspective to real estate. Her experience living, working, raising a family, and contributing to Stonington has given her an intimate understanding of what makes this area so special—and she's eager to share that knowledge with her clients.

Whether you're buying or selling, Elizabeth will professionally guide you through every step of the process, from contract to inspection to a successful closing. Her commitment to exceptional service and local expertise ensures you'll have a trusted advisor by your side throughout your real estate journey.

When she's not working with clients, Elizabeth enjoys swimming and walking the beautiful Rhode Island beaches. She is an active member of the Stonington Garden Club, where she has served on the board and chaired both the Community Gardens and Native Plant Committees, reflecting her dedication to preserving and enhancing the natural beauty of the community she calls home.

Read Less

Read MoreRead Less

Testimonials

Elizabeth is the best realtor hands down, that I have had the pleasure to work with. She knew everything about everything and could be relied on to give the most sensible and practical advice at each step of the home buying process.

Grace and Timothy P

Elizabeth is the consummate professional. Her market strategies and analysis were spot on. She is a kind and caring person who was a pleasure to work with.

James J

Let me start by saying, Elizabeth is outstanding! I have moved and sold and bought houses a number of times in my life. From when I first contacted Elizabeth to sell my home of 16 years, throughout the entire process and closing, Elizabeth was with me and totally accessible and immediately responsive. Elizabeth almost immediately had showings lined up and the house sold in three days! I appreciate Elizabeth’s positive spirit and friendship. Elizabeth is simply outstanding.

Christopher C G

We knew Elizabeth was the right realtor for itus because of her positive attitude and approach and willingness do what was needed. We greatly appreciated her with all of her efforts to help us have a fast turn around with selling our beautiful home! Thank you Elizabeth for everything!

Dan and Karri K

It may seem over the top to give Elizabeth an excellent on each of the points but she was truly superlative on all counts. I came into selling my home with limited experience and she helped with every detail while also being very professional. She brings enthusiasm and energy to the job, working with Elizabeth was an all around great experience!!!

David M S

Elizabeth was wonderful to work with! She helped with everything that was needed and more! It was an absolute pleasure to have her working with us. She is a true professional and an expert. We were able to place all our trust in Elizabeth and she earned our respect as she was there in every step of the process. Elizabeth’s guidance and recommendations were truly appreciated and timely. She completed our property transaction and finalized the sale while meeting all our expectations! Thank you!

AARON & BRIDGET J

Elizabeth has been an absolute rockstar! Words can't express our gratitude for her incredible support during our remote buying journey (Residing in KS, buying in CT). She has single-handedly turned a daunting and stressful process into a smooth and enjoyable experience. As a realtor, she is nothing short of extraordinary! If we ever need a realtor again, Elizabeth will be our first and only choice. Her dedication to her clients is unmatched and shines through in every interaction. It's as if she never sleeps, always working tirelessly to meet her clients' needs. We were blown away when a house popped up on the market at 9 PM EST, and within just an hour, at 10 PM EST, she had our offer submitted. It's hard to find the right words to describe her, but she is an absolute superstar!

Dakota and Haley R

All of the above. Elizabeth was great!

Carol A and David A E

Elizabeth is on your side! She is on top of every detail. She answered any and all questions right away. She helped us feel confident, but realistic in getting our desired outcome and we got it! She is fantastic!

Caroline C S

Elizabeth was such a joy to work with. From our initial conversation I knew she was someone that would actually listen to us and help guide us through the selling of our home, and that is exactly what we experienced. She is clearly passionate about real estate and her clients. I would not hesitate to refer any of my friends or family to Elizabeth.

Jacob M

Elizabeth Johnstone has outstanding knowledge not only of the local market, but also of the changing national real estate market. She has a warm and outgoing personality and was always ready to meet with us and carefully answer all our questions. In addition, Elizabeth has a very keen aesthetic eye. She pointed out what needed refurbishing and provided us with the names of people who could do the work. If you are looking for someone who works tirelessly for your interests in the sale of your house, Elizabeth Johnstone is the real estate agent to call.

George B

Elizabeth arrived the morning after I called to inquire about selling our house. She came prepared with all the necessary documents, including the house history and neighborhood sales data. After a walk-through and a conversation where she explained the 'Coming Soon' rules and the 'Going Live' process, she arranged for a videographer to come the next day! It's a testament to her enthusiasm and skill that the house in New London sold to the first person who walked through the door—a buyer who had flown from Denver, CO, specifically to see it after the MLS listing. While a bit of luck may have been involved, the sale was primarily due to Elizabeth's experience and intuition.

Garrett and Priscilla G

Elizabeth is great! She was full of energy and a fierce advocate for our family. We highly recommend her!

Adam and Kelly V

The entire process of selling our home was seamless with Elizabeth—she immediately handled any issue or task that arose, without us lifting a finger! Not only is her service exceptional, but her attention to detail and foresight in identifying potential obstacles were unlike anything we’ve seen in a real estate professional. My husband and I happily recommend her to any seller or buyer!

Marybeth and Frederick B

Elizabeth is the absolute best and made the purchase of a home in Stonington a seamless and positive process. She was incredibly responsive, knowledgeable about the market, and provided great, direct advice (which is exactly what I wanted!). My husband and I had a less-than-optimal experience with a different agent before, so it was wonderful to have the chance to work with Elizabeth.

Wendy Huang W

I called Elizabeth in the middle of April and asked her if she could help me find a place to live. While I originally wanted to rent, I knew I had to be out of my place on June 1st. While I was doubtful I would find a place in this market Elizabeth said she was sure we would find a place. After looking a week for a rental I knew I would have to buy. There was nothing for rent that came close to what I wanted. Elizabeth's attitude was the same looking for a rental even though she would not be getting paid. This was when I knew she was the agent for me. She didn't care about her take financially, she honestly wanted me to be happy wherever I was to live. We looked at every house in the Mystic, Stonington area. She sent me every house on The MLS website from Westerly to Old Lyme. She told me we had to be active because of the short time we had to work with. There were days when she would drag me out of bed to go look at a house. I had put a deadline in front of her and she was going to make sure we made it. Elizabeth was sure we would find the house of my dreams even though I was in doubt. She was always cheerful and upbeat even though I thought we were losing the battle. We lived in real estate for a month. We found a house where I can be happy for the rest of my life. That might be the end of the story for most people but Elizabeth found me the movers, the utility people to contact, she found me the everyone that I was going to need from electricians to plumbers. She found someone that would help me pack all my stuff. The thing is I am missing a leg and can not do moving. I am very limited physically but she made sure everything was taken care of. She went way beyond what most people think a real estate agent would do. She made my life as easy as it could possibly be. She went far beyond what her job title said she had to do. I know that Elizabeth will not need my recommendation because she is by far the best real estate agent out there. The best I have ever had. The jobs will come to her. If she can put up with me she can deal with anybody. Berkshire Hathaway is lucky to have her. I am lucky to call her my friend for life.

Richard W

Elizabeth is knowledgeable, responsive, and caring. She gives good advice, lets you make the decision, knows the market and the area very well, and goes the extra mile. It was a pleasure to work with Elizabeth.

Kelly M

Elizabeth was knowledgeable, professional and so easy to work with. She helped us navigate the entire process from start to finish. We highly recommend Elizabeth!!!

Susan M

Elizabeth was excellent to work with! She was extremely knowledgeable and helped us get through every step of the home buying process. I would definitely recommend Elizabeth to others looking to buy or rent a house.

Liam S.

My Listings

77 Masons Island Road $1,800,000 link

77 Masons Island Road

Stonington, CT 06355 | New London County
$1,800,000
3 Beds 2/1 Baths 3,235 Sqft 0.48 Acres

Not many homes along the Connecticut coast feature a fabulous second floor great room with water views, a wet bar and a West-facing deck, upon which to relax at the end of the...

3
bed
2/1
bath
3,235
sqft

My Sales

9 Passpataug Avenue $2,650,000 link

9 Passpataug Avenue

Westerly, RI 02891 | Washington County
$2,650,000
5 Beds 3/2 Baths 3,436 Sqft 0.35 Acres

This charming cottage is a once in-a-lifetime coastal living and lifestyle opportunity in one of the most beautiful towns in Rhode Island. This unique property is nestled in the...

5
bed
3/2
bath
3,436
sqft
77 Masons Island Road $1,300,100 link

77 Masons Island Road

Stonington, CT 06355 | New London County
$1,300,100
3 Beds 2/1 Baths 3,245 Sqft 0.48 Acres

You won't want to miss out on this spacious seven room colonial with an adjacent 0.18-acre waterfront lot for your boat with dock potential! The sun pours through the windows in...

3
bed
2/1
bath
3,245
sqft
176 Water Street #2 $1,250,000 link

176 Water Street #2

Stonington, CT 06378 | New London County
$1,250,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 3,744 Sqft

Absolutely stunning penthouse set in one of Stonington Borough most iconic properties, the Honorable Ephraim Williams House of 1840 offers soaring water views of Stonington Harbor....

3
bed
3
bath
3,744
sqft
28 Elm Street $1,200,000 link

28 Elm Street

Stonington, CT 06378 | New London County
$1,200,000
2 Beds 2/1 Baths 1,264 Sqft 0.1 Acres

Welcome to your dream coastal escape! This exquisitely renovated seaside home offers a blend of modern comfort and classic charm, all in mint condition. Enjoy cooking in a chef's...

2
bed
2/1
bath
1,264
sqft
12 Riverside Place $850,000 link

12 Riverside Place

Ledyard, CT 06335 | New London County
$850,000
4 Beds 3 Baths 2,959 Sqft 0.55 Acres

Wonderful opportunity to make this beautiful waterfront Victorian your very own private oasis. Charm galore with wrap-around porch to enjoy cool summer breezes and stunning sunsets...

4
bed
3
bath
2,959
sqft
1 Church Street #E $807,000 link

1 Church Street #E

Stonington, CT 06378 | New London County
$807,000
2 Beds 1/1 Baths 1,136 Sqft

Easy waterfront living in Stonington Village. Here is a rare opportunity to own a beautiful 2 bedroom, 1.5 bath residence overlooking Stonington Harbor in the heart of Stonington...

2
bed
1/1
bath
1,136
sqft
101 Main Street $755,000 link

101 Main Street

Stonington, CT 06378 | New London County
$755,000
4 Beds 1/1 Baths 1,686 Sqft 0.05 Acres

Enjoy coastal life in Stonington Borough in this beautiful 4 bedrooms and 1.5 baths home, which features quartz countertops in the kitchen and an enclosed porch, and french doors....

4
bed
1/1
bath
1,686
sqft
24 Harbor View Terrace $700,000 link

24 Harbor View Terrace

Stonington, CT 06378 | New London County
$700,000
1 Beds 1 Baths 859 Sqft 0.09 Acres

Absolutely charming updated cottage with water views of picturesque Lambert's Cove, beautiful landscaping, and water access! Enjoy sunsets and kayaking on peaceful Lambert's Cove....

1
bed
1
bath
859
sqft
352 Flanders Road $630,000 link

352 Flanders Road

Stonington, CT 06378 | New London County
$630,000
4 Beds 2 Baths 1,796 Sqft 2.6 Acres

Exquisite 4-bedroom, 2-bath Cape Cod set on 2.60 secluded acres, offers a perfect balance of modern amenities and tranquil countryside living. The open floor plan creates a warm...

4
bed
2
bath
1,796
sqft
1663 Center Groton Road $595,000 link

1663 Center Groton Road

Ledyard, CT 06339 | New London County
$595,000
4 Beds 2/1 Baths 2,157 Sqft 1.57 Acres

Welcome to 1663 Center Groton Road in Ledyard, a brand new Colonial nearing completion and ready for your finishing touches. With 2,157 sq. ft. of living space, this home offers...

4
bed
2/1
bath
2,157
sqft
14 Soap House Lane $589,000 link

14 Soap House Lane

Hopkinton, RI 02832 | Washington County
$589,000
4 Beds 3 Baths 3,234 Sqft 0.8 Acres

Fantastic opportunity to own this well cared for home sitting on almost 1 acre located on an 82 acre picturesque lake. Enjoy fishing, swimming, boating, water skiing, Kayaking,...

4
bed
3
bath
3,234
sqft
2000 Route 12 $580,000 link

2000 Route 12

Ledyard, CT 06335 | New London County
$580,000
4 Beds 2 Baths 2,356 Sqft 2.69 Acres

From the moment you enter the driveway, which guides you along majestic trees, you will be captivated by the private natural setting of this beautiful Cape Cod style home. This...

4
bed
2
bath
2,356
sqft