Tammy Tinnerello

Tammy Tinnerello

Realtor ®

Old Lyme Brokerage

103 Halls Road
P.O. Box 489
Old Lyme, CT 06371
  • Born In:
    Westerly, Rhode Island
  • Live In:
    Old Lyme, CT
  • Favorite Movie:
    Breakfast at Tiffanys,The Shawshank Redemption,The Godfather (parts 1, 2 and 3!)
  • Passion:
    Real Estate, Front Doors,Cooking Italian food,and HGTV
  • Interests:
    Football, The Islands, Bird Watching, Pickleball, Cooking, Golfing
  • Favorite Lyric:
    Lovely Day - Bill Withers "When I wake up in the morning..."
  • Can’t Live Without:
    Anything with Blueberries
  • Inspiration:
    My 4 beautiful children!

Since joining the Southeastern Connecticut real estate scene in 2016, Tammy Tinnerello has swiftly risen to become one of the area's most esteemed agents. Her exceptional track record is a testament to her multifaceted expertise, which encompasses formidable negotiating prowess, an astute understanding of market trends, and a reputation for unwavering honesty.

Clients and colleagues alike cherish Tammy's approachable demeanor and integrity, which have been instrumental in forging lasting relationships and a robust network throughout the Shoreline and neighboring communities. Her comprehensive knowledge of local markets, educational institutions, and neighborhood dynamics is invaluable to those navigating the complexities of buying or selling a home.

Tammy's philosophy is rooted in the belief that every new chapter in life begins with the right home. She is dedicated to guiding clients through these pivotal transitions, whether they are seeking a residence to start anew or parting with one to embrace the future.

Beyond her professional endeavors, Tammy is deeply connected to her home in Old Lyme, where she and her husband Joe have raised their four children—Brooke, Salvatore, Bianca, and Lydia. Her West Highland Terrier, Winston, is also a beloved member of the family. Tammy's zest for life extends to her leisure activities, which include golf, pickleball, and culinary explorations. For those on the hunt for their next home, Tammy leverages her intimate knowledge of the region to pinpoint properties that not only meet financial considerations but also embody the lifestyle and amenities her clients desire.

Understanding that a home's presentation can significantly impact its marketability, Tammy offers personalized consultations to enhance its attractiveness. Her strategic recommendations, whether staging, or simple aesthetic touches, are designed to captivate the ideal audience and maximize the property's value.

With Tammy Tinnerello, you're not just finding an agent—you're gaining a partner committed to realizing your real estate aspirations with passion, expertise, and a personal touch.

Since joining the Southeastern Connecticut real estate scene in 2016, Tammy Tinnerello has swiftly risen to become one of the area's most esteemed agents. Her exceptional track record is a testament to her multifaceted expertise, which encompasses formidable negotiating prowess, an astute understanding of market trends, and a reputation for unwavering honesty.

Clients and colleagues alike cherish Tammy's approachable demeanor and integrity, which have been instrumental in forging lasting relationships and a robust network throughout the Shoreline and neighboring communities. Her comprehensive knowledge of local markets, educational institutions, and neighborhood dynamics is invaluable to those navigating the complexities of buying or selling a home.

Tammy's philosophy is rooted in the belief that every new chapter in life begins with the right home. She is dedicated to guiding clients through these pivotal transitions, whether they are seeking a residence to start anew or parting with one to embrace the future.

Beyond her professional endeavors, Tammy is deeply connected to her home in Old Lyme, where she and her husband Joe have raised their four children—Brooke, Salvatore, Bianca, and Lydia. Her West Highland Terrier, Winston, is also a beloved member of the family. Tammy's zest for life extends to her leisure activities, which include golf, pickleball, and culinary explorations. For those on the hunt for their next home, Tammy leverages her intimate knowledge of the region to pinpoint properties that not only meet financial considerations but also embody the lifestyle and amenities her clients desire.

Understanding that a home's presentation can significantly impact its marketability, Tammy offers personalized consultations to enhance its attractiveness. Her strategic recommendations, whether staging, or simple aesthetic touches, are designed to captivate the ideal audience and maximize the property's value.

With Tammy Tinnerello, you're not just finding an agent—you're gaining a partner committed to realizing your real estate aspirations with passion, expertise, and a personal touch.

Since joining the Southeastern Connecticut real estate scene in 2016, Tammy Tinnerello has swiftly risen to become one of the area's most esteemed agents. Her exceptional track record is a testament to her multifaceted expertise, which encompasses formidable negotiating prowess, an astute understanding of market trends, and a reputation for unwavering honesty.

Clients and colleagues alike cherish Tammy's approachable demeanor and integrity, which have been instrumental in forging lasting relationships and a robust network throughout the Shoreline and neighboring communities. Her comprehensive knowledge of local markets, educational institutions, and neighborhood dynamics is invaluable to those navigating the complexities of buying or selling a home.

Tammy's philosophy is rooted in the belief that every new chapter in life begins with the right home. She is dedicated to guiding clients through these pivotal transitions, whether they are seeking a residence to start anew or parting with one to embrace the future.

Beyond her professional endeavors, Tammy is deeply connected to her home in Old Lyme, where she and her husband Joe have raised their four children—Brooke, Salvatore, Bianca, and Lydia. Her West Highland Terrier, Winston, is also a beloved member of the family. Tammy's zest for life extends to her leisure activities, which include golf, pickleball, and culinary explorations. For those on the hunt for their next home, Tammy leverages her intimate knowledge of the region to pinpoint properties that not only meet financial considerations but also embody the lifestyle and amenities her clients desire.

Understanding that a home's presentation can significantly impact its marketability, Tammy offers personalized consultations to enhance its attractiveness. Her strategic recommendations, whether staging, or simple aesthetic touches, are designed to captivate the ideal audience and maximize the property's value.

With Tammy Tinnerello, you're not just finding an agent—you're gaining a partner committed to realizing your real estate aspirations with passion, expertise, and a personal touch.

Read Less

Read MoreRead Less
  • Awards
    • #7 in Dollar Volume, Company-Wide, 2024
    • #3 in Units, Company-Wide, 2024
    • #3 Dollar Volume, #4 Sold units Company-Wide
    • Diamond Award, 2020, 2021, 2022,2023, 2024
    • Circle of Excellence First and Second Quarters of 2021, 2022
    • #1 in Dollar Volume and Units, Old Lyme Brokerage, 2021, 2022,2023, 2024
  • Specialities
    • Member of The Institute For Luxury Home Marketing

Testimonials

We simply cannot express how grateful and appreciative we are to have had Tammy Tinnerello as our listing and buying agent. She was professional and engaged throughout the entire process. When issues arose, she was always accessible. We would highly recommend this seasoned professional and would never use anyone else. Thank you Tammy for making selling and buying a new home a memorable and enjoyable experience! Fondly, Kim & Ken Bartlett

Kimberly & Kenneth Bartlett

My son did research on who would be the best agent to sell my house and Tammy was the one we picked. I couldn’t be happier with our choice. Thank you Tammy for all your hard work.

Diane Bailey

I had a truly exceptional experience working with Tammy to sell my home in Waterford—especially during what turned out to be a challenging moment in the market. I met with three other realtors before choosing Tammy, and I never once second-guessed my decision. From start to finish, she made me feel supported, informed, and genuinely cared for. Tammy consistently went above and beyond—bringing fresh flowers for showings, adding thoughtful touches for the open house, and always showing up with warmth and professionalism. She’s not only personable and easy to work with, but also sharp, strategic, and deeply knowledgeable about the local market. I wholeheartedly recommend Tammy to anyone looking for a realtor they can truly trust, and I would gladly work with her again on either the buying or selling side of a future transaction. Thank you, Tammy! Willa Kammerer

Willa Kammerer

Tammy Tinnerello helped me in a very professional manner. Everything was smooth sailing, selling my home in Chester and buying a home in Old Lyme. I will surely recommend William Pitt / Julia B Fee Sotheby's to my friends and family . Thank you . UMA

Uma Rao

xxx

Ernesto & Kathleen Canalis

Excellent agent who works through impediments while maintaining a professional demeanor. I would highly recommend Tammy Tinnerello as a Realtor.

Raymond S. King Executor

Searching for a new home on the Connecticut shoreline we fell in love with the town of Old Lyme. Tammy’s intimate knowledge of the community helped us to quickly find the ideal home for our needs in a difficult market. She was wonderful to work with.

Gerlinde Berger-Walliser

The experience was seamless, start to finish! Tammy is great to work with, and understood exactly what we were looking for. Highly recommend!

Lisa Diamond & Larry Wasser

Tammy is ABSOLUTELY THE BEST!!! Her dedication and work ethic for her clients is to be commended. She goes ABOVE AND BEYOND her scope of responsibilities as a realtor! She made the transaction of selling our estate smooth and seamless during our most difficult time! THANK YOU FOR BEING YOU TAMMY!!! You were truly a blessing to work with!!!!!

Troy Peters

Tammy was very helpful throughout our home buying experience and was able to work to make sure we were getting the best value possible. Her experience was evident and we were glad to be able to work with her.

Joshua and Kimberly Ballestrini

Tammy was exceptional and with her enthusiasm and guidance selling our home was a seamless process. Very grateful for her help. Highly recommend.

Michael Michelsen Paula L. Halloran

Tammy Tinnerello is the only RA agent we work with in CT. Thank you!

Schramma Properties LLC, Edgar Schramma

Tammy T helped ensure our first home purchase went as smooth as possible; she made great recommendations, was an excellent communicator, and everything was completed very quickly. Thanks to Tammy we are in a wonderful new home!

Michael and Deanna Gabiga

Tammy is extremely dedicated , knowledgable, and a wonderful to work with as a real estate agent. Attorney Francis Sablone

Landing LLC

Tammy Tinnerello has her client’s best interest at heart. She knows the real estate market inside and out and will give you excellent advice. Whether you’re buying or selling, she listens to you and gets you through to a successful conclusion.

Susan Zilke

I had a great experience and felt like Tammy, my realtor, was looking out for me! She was honest, dependable, and always answered my questions.

David Philip martel and Stacey Beth Martel

Fantastic, it's a pleasure.

Old Lyme CT Properties Corp

Team Tammy was amazing and they handled every challenge along the way with enthusiasm and professionalism. From the consideration and planning on how to properly bring the house to market through show casing the house and handling prospective buyers, and ultimately through negotiations of a successful sale, we could not have been more pleased.

Richard E Shriver

Knowledgeable and very responsive ...

Fran Sablone

Tammy is outstanding! I couldn't have been happier with her helping me find a home. It took awhile and she was always positive and encouraging. I will recommend her to all my friends in the market.

Michael Francis Soriano

Tammy Tinnerell was v professional and understood what we were looking for. She kept us informed, and so when the house came back on the market, she immediately informed us.

Paula M Goldsmith and Jonathan P Brecht

Tammy was a fantastic advisor to our family during our home buying experience. She was thoughtful, patient, knowledgeable and brought the right level of intensity to ensure our needs were met. We thoroughly endorse William Pitt / Tammy.

Nathaniel P & Carolyn Walsh Stone

I've enjoyed all the transactions Tammy has helped us with over the past 2 years.

Schramma Properties, LLC

Tammy was right there all through the process. We really enjoyed working with her. She explained things carefully and was always available to answer questions.

James C and Madelynn D Zwernrmann

Tammy T and those who filled in as needed (Chrissy and Tony) were excellent.

Caren B and Laurence Peters

very professional with Kindness and respect

Frama Realty Corp or its assignee

Working with Tammy Tinnerello was simply a pleasure. From the start, she was so helpful and positive. She brought her energy and enthusiasm to work every day. At in every juncture during the selling process, she was there to guide us through it. Her advertising of our property was spectacular. Any questions or issues that arose were quickly answered and resolved. Tammy was personable and professional and took the time throughout the whole to be truly present. We would highly recommend hiring Tammy as your agent! Thank You Tammy! Greg and Kathy Hancock

Kathleen P Hancock

Tammy is a fantastic agent. It's a good feeling to know that she always has our best interests in mind. We completely trust her advice and judgement.

Lori A. Strobel

Tammy Tinnerello was an amazing agent to work with. She understood our needs from the beginning to the end of the process.

Sheryl and Greg Shyloski

Tammy Tinnerello is an excellent agent. She spent the time needed to make the right decisions on real estate purchases. Tammy has my loyalty for all future business. Edgar Schramma

Edgar Schramma

Tammy is both an excellent realtor and a kind and patient person. It was a pleasure working with her.

Kathy Ridgway, Arthur Pomerante

Tammy was great and helped us thru what proved to be a challenging final few days leading up to the purchase. She was very engaged and really went above and beyond for us.

Benjamin A and Meghan M Merris

Tammy did an awesome job!!

James Montana

My Listings

15A Shore Road $2,495,000 link

15A Shore Road

Waterford, CT 06385 | New London County
$2,495,000
4 Beds 3/1 Baths 9,399 Sqft 1.83 Acres

As featured in JamesEdition: Every moment feels like a retreat for guests of all ages at this completely remodeled and expanded Colonial at 15A Shore Rd. Fully renovated in 2020,...

4
bed
3/1
bath
9,399
sqft
8 Lieutenant River Lane $1,600,000 link

8 Lieutenant River Lane

Old Lyme, CT 06371 | New London County
$1,600,000
3 Beds 2/1 Baths 2,215 Sqft 0.21 Acres

Welcome to 8 Lieutenant River Lane, an exquisitely renovated colonial in the heart of Old Lyme Village, where timeless charm meets contemporary luxury. This meticulously updated...

3
bed
2/1
bath
2,215
sqft
23 Lords Meadow Lane $1,300,000 link

23 Lords Meadow Lane

Old Lyme, CT 06371 | New London County
$1,300,000
4 Beds 5/1 Baths 3,293 Sqft 2.02 Acres

Introducing an exceptional new construction estate on the serene Lords Meadow Lane in Old Lyme, Connecticut, an exclusive collection of distinguished residences crafted for the...

4
bed
5/1
bath
3,293
sqft

My Sales

159 River Road $4,600,000 link

159 River Road

Essex, CT 06426 | Middlesex County
$4,600,000
4 Beds 5/1 Baths 5,142 Sqft 3.03 Acres

This stunning waterfront home boasts breathtaking water views with direct frontage on the Connecticut River. Enter through the custom leaded front door into an open plan on the...

4
bed
5/1
bath
5,142
sqft
9 Whisper Cove Road $3,400,000 link

9 Whisper Cove Road

Old Saybrook, CT 06475 | Middlesex County
$3,400,000
4 Beds 3/2 Baths 4,768 Sqft 1.92 Acres

Nestled in the picturesque town of Old Saybrook, this exquisite Colonial-style home offers a blend of traditional charm and modern living. With captivating views of the nearby...

4
bed
3/2
bath
4,768
sqft
450 Maple Avenue $3,200,000 link

450 Maple Avenue

Old Saybrook, CT 06475 | Middlesex County
$3,200,000
3 Beds 3/2 Baths 4,435 Sqft 0.3 Acres

**Stunning Waterfront Home at Knollwood Beach** Discover unparalleled luxury in this meticulously updated prime front-row residence overlooking Long Island Sound. Floor-to-ceiling...

3
bed
3/2
bath
4,435
sqft
86 Montauk Avenue $2,900,000 link

86 Montauk Avenue

Stonington, CT 06378 | New London County
$2,900,000
4 Beds 5/1 Baths 5,050 Sqft 1.26 Acres

Experience the luxury of refined country living in this meticulously renovated home, nestled in the highly desirable Montauk Avenue area of Stonington with views of Stonington...

4
bed
5/1
bath
5,050
sqft
18 Ferry Road $2,895,000 link

18 Ferry Road

Old Lyme, CT 06371 | New London County
$2,895,000
6 Beds 6/1 Baths 6,305 Sqft 1.07 Acres

In the heart of Old Lyme at 18 Ferry Road, where history whispers through the trees, there lies an enchanting 1890 home, a setting so magical it was chosen for the Hallmark movie...

6
bed
6/1
bath
6,305
sqft
44 Ferry Road $2,695,000 link

44 Ferry Road

Lyme, CT 06371 | New London County
$2,695,000
4 Beds 5/1 Baths 6,510 Sqft 20 Acres

44 Ferry Road is a gracious estate offering 20 acres of privacy and sweeping panoramic views of the Connecticut River Valley. Enter the main residence through the dramatic front...

4
bed
5/1
bath
6,510
sqft
848-850 Noank Road $2,640,000 link

848-850 Noank Road

Groton, CT 06355 | New London County
$2,640,000
8 Beds 6/1 Baths 4,270 Sqft 2.22 Acres

Welcome to multigenerational living!! Step into history at the storied home of Captain Silas Beebe, beautifully preserved on the shores of the cove that bears his name. This remarkable...

8
bed
6/1
bath
4,270
sqft
23 Talcott Farm Road $2,495,000 link

23 Talcott Farm Road

Old Lyme, CT 06371 | New London County
$2,495,000
5 Beds 5/1 Baths 5,611 Sqft 2.2 Acres

In the tradition of design excellence, the beauty of the location enters and melds into the beauty of the home. Look through the foyer, through the great room, through a wall of...

5
bed
5/1
bath
5,611
sqft
12 Lambs Way $2,350,000 link

12 Lambs Way

Stonington, CT 06378 | New London County
$2,350,000
5 Beds 5/1 Baths 5,659 Sqft 1.15 Acres

Welcome to 12 Lambs Way, an exquisite custom-built home spanning an impressive 5600+ square feet. This architectural gem seamlessly blends timeless elegance with modern luxury,...

5
bed
5/1
bath
5,659
sqft
49 Parkers Point Road $2,300,000 link

49 Parkers Point Road

Chester, CT 06412 | Middlesex County
$2,300,000
6 Beds 4/1 Baths 3,968 Sqft 6 Acres

Welcome to this stunning contemporary home nestled on the banks of the Connecticut River in charming Chester, CT. With its sleek design, modern amenities, and unparalleled riverfront...

6
bed
4/1
bath
3,968
sqft
3 Sea Meadows Lane $2,270,000 link

3 Sea Meadows Lane

Waterford, CT 06385 | New London County
$2,270,000
4 Beds 5/1 Baths 5,488 Sqft 0.43 Acres

Welcome to your dream of relaxed coastal living in this beautifully designed award winning Nantucket-style home, nestled in the sought-after Strand neighborhood. This distinguished...

4
bed
5/1
bath
5,488
sqft