Allyson Cotton

Associate Broker

Allyson Cotton

Allyson Cotton

Associate Broker

Old Lyme Brokerage

103 Halls Road
P.O. Box 489
Old Lyme, CT 06371

Team Leader for the Award Winning A Team of Old Lyme

With four decades of sales excellence, Allyson Cotton transforms the home buying and selling experience into a seamless, stress-free journey for clients throughout the Shoreline area.

Allyson's career began as an entrepreneur, founding and building a thriving firm that marketed home furniture and decorative accessories to retailers nationwide. That foundation gave her the tools she brings to every transaction today: an entrepreneurial mindset, exceptional follow-through, expert negotiation skills, and meticulous attention to detail—all laser-focused on her clients' success...

With four decades of sales excellence, Allyson Cotton transforms the home buying and selling experience into a seamless, stress-free journey for clients throughout the Shoreline area.

Allyson's career began as an entrepreneur, founding and building a thriving firm that marketed home furniture and decorative accessories to retailers nationwide. That foundation gave her the tools she brings to every transaction today: an entrepreneurial mindset, exceptional follow-through, expert negotiation skills, and meticulous attention to detail—all laser-focused on her clients' success.

Now in her 21st year as a top-producing real estate professional, Allyson's passion for the industry has only deepened. She doesn't just help clients meet their goals—she exceeds them.

What Sets Allyson Apart:

• Master Negotiator – Decades of professional deal-making experience
• Detail-Obsessed – Exceptionally organized and thorough at every step
• Problem Solver – Tenacious, creative, and solution-focused
• Marketing Innovator – Cutting-edge strategies spanning direct mail, social media, video, staging, and beyond
• Local Expert – 30+ years living in and loving the Lyme and Shoreline communities

The A Team Advantage

As founder and leader of The A Team at William Pitt Sotheby's International Realty, Allyson leads a collective of like-minded real estate professionals united by a single mission: delivering results for buyers and sellers through passion and perseverance.

Passion + Perseverance = Results

With four decades of sales excellence, Allyson Cotton transforms the home buying and selling experience into a seamless, stress-free journey for clients throughout the Shoreline area.

Allyson's career began as an entrepreneur, founding and building a thriving firm that marketed home furniture and decorative accessories to retailers nationwide. That foundation gave her the tools she brings to every transaction today: an entrepreneurial mindset, exceptional follow-through, expert negotiation skills, and meticulous attention to detail—all laser-focused on her clients' success.

Now in her 21st year as a top-producing real estate professional, Allyson's passion for the industry has only deepened. She doesn't just help clients meet their goals—she exceeds them.

What Sets Allyson Apart:

• Master Negotiator – Decades of professional deal-making experience
• Detail-Obsessed – Exceptionally organized and thorough at every step
• Problem Solver – Tenacious, creative, and solution-focused
• Marketing Innovator – Cutting-edge strategies spanning direct mail, social media, video, staging, and beyond
• Local Expert – 30+ years living in and loving the Lyme and Shoreline communities

The A Team Advantage

As founder and leader of The A Team at William Pitt Sotheby's International Realty, Allyson leads a collective of like-minded real estate professionals united by a single mission: delivering results for buyers and sellers through passion and perseverance.

Passion + Perseverance = Results

Read MoreRead Less
  • Agent Designations
    • Accredited Buyer Representative
    • Graduate, REALTOR® Institute
    • Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker
    • Certified Relocation Specialist
    • Waterfront Property Specialist
  • Awards
    • 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023,2024 #1 Team Old Lyme office for dollar volume
    • 2020, 2022, 2023,2024 #1 Team Old Lyme office for units sold
    • 2019, 2020 Platinum Award Winner William Pitt Sotheby's
    • 2016,2017, 2018, 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024 Gold Award Winner William Pitt Sotheby's
    • 2014 Silver Award Winner William Pitt Sotheby's
    • 2013 Bronze Award Winner William Pitt Sotheby's
    • #1 Producing Agent in Dollar Volume, Old Lyme Brokerage, 2017 2020
    • #2 Producing Agent in Dollar Volume, Old Lyme Brokerage,2017, 2019
    • Top 10 Agent for Units Sold 2019 William Pitt Award Winner
    • Five Star Real Estate Agent 2011-2024 (15 years)
  • Interests
    • Golfing
    • Biking
    • Kayaking