Amy Graham

Amy Graham

Realtor

Old Lyme Brokerage

103 Halls Road
P.O. Box 489
Old Lyme, CT 06371

"Whether she is navigating a high-stakes negotiation or guiding a first-time seller through a complex closing, Amy offers her clients both a steady hand and a distinct competitive advantage."

  • Born In:
    Texas
  • Live In:
    Chester
  • Favorite Movie:
    I have so many!
  • Passion:
    Family & Community
  • Interests:
    Gardening, Beachcombing, and Psychology
  • Favorite Lyric:
    "Let your soul and spirit fly into the mystic."
  • Can’t Live Without:
    Coffee AND Sun, water, and sand!
  • Inspiration:
    My kiddos :-)

Amy Graham delivers an elevated, deeply personalized real estate experience for her sellers and buyers across the Connecticut River Valley and Shoreline. As a key member of the award-winning A Team at William Pitt Sotheby’s International Realty, she seamlessly pairs the global prestige of a luxury brand with the collaborative power of a top-producing team. Grounded by a consistent track record of success, Amy views real estate not as a transaction, but as a heartfelt commitment to guiding clients seamlessly into their next chapter.

What truly gives Amy's clients a distinct competitive advantage is her masterful approach to communication and negotiation. Holding a Master’s degree in Psychology, her background includes over two decades as a college professor and specialized experience in federal psychological assessment. This foundation gives her a rare mastery of human dynamics, sharp emotional intelligence, and absolute discretion—translating into advanced negotiation strategies that fiercely protect her clients' interests while keeping the process calm and grounded.

An expert in virtual transaction management, Amy uses data-driven insights to maximize market positioning, navigating changing markets with a steady, reassuring hand. She pairs this sharp professional acumen with the profound empathy and logistical precision she mastered as a Veteran's spouse. 

Deeply rooted in the Tri-Town community, Amy balances her global corporate reach with local devotion. She and her husband, Nick, founded the nonprofit Valley Lacrosse Club and lead the VRHS Boys Lacrosse Booster Club, working tirelessly to remove barriers to youth sports through fundraising and mentorship. Amy brings this exact same passion, local advocacy, and protective dedication to her real estate practice, bringing warm, compassionate leadership and elite strategy to the closing table.

***

2024 Top Office Team Award #1 in Volume & #1 in Units

2024 Bronze Award Winner

2025 RealTrends Verified Top Team

2025 Bronze Award Winner

2026 FIVE STAR - Rising Star Award Winner

Amy Graham delivers an elevated, deeply personalized real estate experience for her sellers and buyers across the Connecticut River Valley and Shoreline. As a key member of the award-winning A Team at William Pitt Sotheby’s International Realty, she seamlessly pairs the global prestige of a luxury brand with the collaborative power of a top-producing team. Grounded by a consistent track record of success, Amy views real estate not as a transaction, but as a heartfelt commitment to guiding clients seamlessly into their next chapter.

What truly gives Amy's clients a distinct competitive advantage is her masterful approach to communication and negotiation. Holding a Master’s degree in Psychology, her background includes over two decades as a college professor and specialized experience in federal psychological assessment. This foundation gives her a rare mastery of human dynamics, sharp emotional intelligence, and absolute discretion—translating into advanced negotiation strategies that fiercely protect her clients' interests while keeping the process calm and grounded.

An expert in virtual transaction management, Amy uses data-driven insights to maximize market positioning, navigating changing markets with a steady, reassuring hand. She pairs this sharp professional acumen with the profound empathy and logistical precision she mastered as a Veteran's spouse. 

Deeply rooted in the Tri-Town community, Amy balances her global corporate reach with local devotion. She and her husband, Nick, founded the nonprofit Valley Lacrosse Club and lead the VRHS Boys Lacrosse Booster Club, working tirelessly to remove barriers to youth sports through fundraising and mentorship. Amy brings this exact same passion, local advocacy, and protective dedication to her real estate practice, bringing warm, compassionate leadership and elite strategy to the closing table.

***

2024 Top Office Team Award #1 in Volume & #1 in Units

2024 Bronze Award Winner

2025 RealTrends Verified Top Team

2025 Bronze Award Winner

2026 FIVE STAR - Rising Star Award Winner

Amy Graham delivers an elevated, deeply personalized real estate experience for her sellers and buyers across the Connecticut River Valley and Shoreline. As a key member of the award-winning A Team at William Pitt Sotheby’s International Realty, she seamlessly pairs the global prestige of a luxury brand with the collaborative power of a top-producing team. Grounded by a consistent track record of success, Amy views real estate not as a transaction, but as a heartfelt commitment to guiding clients seamlessly into their next chapter.

What truly gives Amy's clients a distinct competitive advantage is her masterful approach to communication and negotiation. Holding a Master’s degree in Psychology, her background includes over two decades as a college professor and specialized experience in federal psychological assessment. This foundation gives her a rare mastery of human dynamics, sharp emotional intelligence, and absolute discretion—translating into advanced negotiation strategies that fiercely protect her clients' interests while keeping the process calm and grounded.

An expert in virtual transaction management, Amy uses data-driven insights to maximize market positioning, navigating changing markets with a steady, reassuring hand. She pairs this sharp professional acumen with the profound empathy and logistical precision she mastered as a Veteran's spouse. 

Deeply rooted in the Tri-Town community, Amy balances her global corporate reach with local devotion. She and her husband, Nick, founded the nonprofit Valley Lacrosse Club and lead the VRHS Boys Lacrosse Booster Club, working tirelessly to remove barriers to youth sports through fundraising and mentorship. Amy brings this exact same passion, local advocacy, and protective dedication to her real estate practice, bringing warm, compassionate leadership and elite strategy to the closing table.

***

2024 Top Office Team Award #1 in Volume & #1 in Units

2024 Bronze Award Winner

2025 RealTrends Verified Top Team

2025 Bronze Award Winner

2026 FIVE STAR - Rising Star Award Winner

Read Less

Read MoreRead Less
  • Awards
    • 2024 Top Office Team Award #1 in Volume & #1 in Units
    • 2024 Bronze Award Winner
    • 2025 Bronze Award Winner
    • 2026 FIVE STAR RISING STAR AWARD WINNER
  • Specialities
    • Relocations
    • Military/Veterans/DOD
    • The River Valley & Shoreline
    • Chester
    • Deep River
    • Essex
    • Killingworth
    • Old Saybrook
    • Lyme & Old Lyme
    • Clinton
    • Westbrook

Testimonials

Amy kept us informed throughout the listing and selling process. We sold our home within a week for list price. Our movers did not complete the move on the specified date. Amy was invaluable as she kept the buyers' agent updated while she worked beside us to get everything out of the house.

Cindy Fortner

Our agent was great!

Rebecca T.

As a first-time home buyer, I was nervous and unsure about what to expect, but working with Amy Graham made the entire process smooth and clear. From our very first conversation, Amy was incredibly responsive, always available to answer my many questions—no matter how big or small. Her reassuring presence made the entire process feel manageable and stress-free, and her deep knowledge of the market gave me the clarity and confidence to make informed decisions. Amy’s resourcefulness was invaluable—whether it was connecting me with trusted professionals, helping me understand paperwork, or navigating tricky negotiations, she always had a solution or suggestion ready. I truly felt like she was in my corner throughout the entire journey. I can’t thank Amy enough for her guidance and support. Thanks to her, I found a home I love and had a positive first experience buying real estate. I would absolutely recommend her to anyone, especially first-time buyers like me!

Jayne M.

Amy helped and supported us every step of the way in the process of buying our first home. Amy always had our best interest in mind and her knowledge and experience was pivotal in assuring we weren’t taken advantage of by any other parties. I would highly recommend Amy to anyone in the market for a real estate agent in Old Lyme and surrounding areas.

Vincenzo Cicco

I chose Amy as my realtor because she had recently sold a similarly challenging home to mine. From the moment she stepped into my house, her uplifting outlook and eye for the beautiful things my house offered (not always apparent to the person living there) helped me believe I was doing the right thing at the right time. She worked with me regarding the timing of the listing and made herself available as needed for showings and an open house, all of which resulted in many legitimate offers and a sale contract in 6 days. One part of her craft that stood out to me was the amazing prose she used in the homes description. Without being flowery or false, she captured exactly the spirit of a home with simple and understated character, in a way I am sure excited the imagination of many prospective homebuyers. Amy Graham is a real professional and I would recommend her to anyone looking to sell their home.

Jim Paradis

Amy treated me with kindness and respect from the first moment. Seamless! I felt like I was her focus and she was working for me. We were able to close quickly and easily! Amy and her team will get the job done for you.

Sylvia Hooghkirk

My Listings

150 Ferry Road #Gatehouse $8,000/mo link

150 Ferry Road #Gatehouse

Lyme, CT 06439 | New London County
$8,000/mo
3 Beds 3/1 Baths 2,766 Sqft 0.5 Acres

Lovely Furnished Summer Rental available in the Ferry Landing District of Hadlyme. The perfect spot to escape and enjoy the Lower Connecticut River Valley and everything it has...

3
bed
3/1
bath
2,766
sqft
Goose Hill Road $145,000 link

Goose Hill Road

Chester, CT 06412 | Middlesex County
$145,000
4.91 Acres

New to the market! Discover the perfect canvas for your dream home on this beautiful, private 4.91-acre wooded lot. Nestled within a private 8-lot subdivision just off Goose Hill...

4.91
acre

My Sales

45 Prospect Street $1,100,000 link

45 Prospect Street

Groton, CT 06355 | New London County
$1,100,000
4 Beds 4 Baths 3,458 Sqft 0.71 Acres

Welcome to 45 Prospect Street, a beautifully maintained and thoughtfully designed residence in the charming village of Mystic, CT. This 4-bedroom, 4-bathroom home, constructed...

4
bed
4
bath
3,458
sqft
36-1 Sterling City Road $750,000 link

36-1 Sterling City Road

Lyme, CT 06371 | New London County
$750,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 2,240 Sqft 2.06 Acres

All that Lyme has to offer is right outside your windows. This home is magnificently sighted on a hillside overlooking Tiffany Farms, with glimpses of Hamburg Cove in the distance,...

3
bed
2
bath
2,240
sqft
8 Butter Jones Road $715,000 link

8 Butter Jones Road

Chester, CT 06412 | Middlesex County
$715,000
3 Beds 2/1 Baths 2,139 Sqft 2.01 Acres

Enchanting Cape with Artisan Post & Beam Charm - Just Down the Road from Chester Village! Tucked away on 2 acres of picturesque land, this whimsical 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath Cape Cod...

3
bed
2/1
bath
2,139
sqft
51 West Shore Drive $551,000 link

51 West Shore Drive

Haddam, CT 06441 | Middlesex County
$551,000
3 Beds 1 Baths 899 Sqft 0.34 Acres

This just might be your COOL spot on the water for our steamy summer. Direct waterfront on 40 acre Hidden Lake which is stream and spring fed. For your enjoyment, there is a deck...

3
bed
1
bath
899
sqft
23 Spring Street $550,000 link

23 Spring Street

Chester, CT 06412 | Middlesex County
$550,000
2 Beds 1/1 Baths 1,104 Sqft 1.06 Acres

This precious 1920 bungalow has had only 2 owners! It has been updated and extremely well cared for. Central a/c, 2 bedrooms, 1 1/2 baths, full basement, and the most perfect front...

2
bed
1/1
bath
1,104
sqft
52 Sima Road $485,000 link

52 Sima Road

Haddam, CT 06441 | Middlesex County
$485,000
3 Beds 2/1 Baths 2,032 Sqft 2.4 Acres

Prepare to be amazed! This circa 1740 Cape has been beautifully renovated and thoughtfully transformed while preserving all the warmth and charm that New Englanders cherish in...

3
bed
2/1
bath
2,032
sqft
17 Boston Post Road $465,000 link

17 Boston Post Road

Old Lyme, CT 06371 | New London County
$465,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 1,516 Sqft 0.92 Acres

Located just north of Old Lyme village, this shingle ranch sits well back, framed by century old stone walls. Enter through the three-season porch with slate floor. Three steps...

3
bed
2
bath
1,516
sqft
9 Gilbert Hill Road $400,000 link

9 Gilbert Hill Road

Chester, CT 06412 | Middlesex County
$400,000
2 Beds 1/1 Baths 2,008 Sqft 0.52 Acres

Great location just outside of Chester Village on a quiet cul de sac street. Main level features a living room with hardwood floors, kitchen with hardwood floors, large family...

2
bed
1/1
bath
2,008
sqft
103 Goose Hill Road $400,000 link

103 Goose Hill Road

Chester, CT 06412 | Middlesex County
$400,000
3 Beds 1/1 Baths 1,560 Sqft 2.04 Acres

Experience the enchantment of quiet country living with this quintessential vintage farmhouse in Chester, Connecticut. Nestled on a tranquil 2.04-acre plot, this home offers a...

3
bed
1/1
bath
1,560
sqft
9 School Lane $375,000 link

9 School Lane

Chester, CT 06412 | Middlesex County
$375,000
3 Beds 1/1 Baths 1,388 Sqft 2.04 Acres

A RARE FIND IN CHESTER VILLAGE! This is your opportunity to create a private retreat on over two acres of land in the heart of Chester Village! A golden opportunity awaits those...

3
bed
1/1
bath
1,388
sqft
22 Prospect Street $330,000 link

22 Prospect Street

Deep River, CT 06417 | Middlesex County
$330,000
2 Beds 1 Baths 1,080 Sqft 0.25 Acres

MULTIPLE OFFERS RECEIVED. PLEASE SUBMIT BEST AND FINAL OFFERS BY 5:00 PM ON THURSDAY, MAY 1ST...Great opportunity in the quaint town of Deep River! A gorgeous remodeled kitchen...

2
bed
1
bath
1,080
sqft
75 Old Pent Road $3,300/mo link

75 Old Pent Road

Westbrook, CT 06498 | Middlesex County
$3,300/mo
2 Beds 1/1 Baths 1,540 Sqft 0.38 Acres

Enchanting seaside residence with dramatic views, steps away from Westbrook beaches and an easy walk to town and restaurants. This spacious, new construction home has all the amenities...

2
bed
1/1
bath
1,540
sqft