Allyson Cotton

Associate Broker

Allyson Cotton

Allyson Cotton

Associate Broker

Old Lyme Brokerage

103 Halls Road
P.O. Box 489
Old Lyme, CT 06371
Visit my website

Team Leader for the Award Winning A Team of Old Lyme

With four decades of sales excellence, Allyson Cotton transforms the home buying and selling experience into a seamless, stress-free journey for clients throughout the Shoreline area.

Allyson's career began as an entrepreneur, founding and building a thriving firm that marketed home furniture and decorative accessories to retailers nationwide. That foundation gave her the tools she brings to every transaction today: an entrepreneurial mindset, exceptional follow-through, expert negotiation skills, and meticulous attention to detail—all laser-focused on her clients' success...

With four decades of sales excellence, Allyson Cotton transforms the home buying and selling experience into a seamless, stress-free journey for clients throughout the Shoreline area.

Allyson's career began as an entrepreneur, founding and building a thriving firm that marketed home furniture and decorative accessories to retailers nationwide. That foundation gave her the tools she brings to every transaction today: an entrepreneurial mindset, exceptional follow-through, expert negotiation skills, and meticulous attention to detail—all laser-focused on her clients' success.

Now in her 21st year as a top-producing real estate professional, Allyson's passion for the industry has only deepened. She doesn't just help clients meet their goals—she exceeds them.

What Sets Allyson Apart:

• Master Negotiator – Decades of professional deal-making experience
• Detail-Obsessed – Exceptionally organized and thorough at every step
• Problem Solver – Tenacious, creative, and solution-focused
• Marketing Innovator – Cutting-edge strategies spanning direct mail, social media, video, staging, and beyond
• Local Expert – 30+ years living in and loving the Lyme and Shoreline communities

The A Team Advantage

As founder and leader of The A Team at William Pitt Sotheby's International Realty, Allyson leads a collective of like-minded real estate professionals united by a single mission: delivering results for buyers and sellers through passion and perseverance.

Passion + Perseverance = Results

With four decades of sales excellence, Allyson Cotton transforms the home buying and selling experience into a seamless, stress-free journey for clients throughout the Shoreline area.

Allyson's career began as an entrepreneur, founding and building a thriving firm that marketed home furniture and decorative accessories to retailers nationwide. That foundation gave her the tools she brings to every transaction today: an entrepreneurial mindset, exceptional follow-through, expert negotiation skills, and meticulous attention to detail—all laser-focused on her clients' success.

Now in her 21st year as a top-producing real estate professional, Allyson's passion for the industry has only deepened. She doesn't just help clients meet their goals—she exceeds them.

What Sets Allyson Apart:

• Master Negotiator – Decades of professional deal-making experience
• Detail-Obsessed – Exceptionally organized and thorough at every step
• Problem Solver – Tenacious, creative, and solution-focused
• Marketing Innovator – Cutting-edge strategies spanning direct mail, social media, video, staging, and beyond
• Local Expert – 30+ years living in and loving the Lyme and Shoreline communities

The A Team Advantage

As founder and leader of The A Team at William Pitt Sotheby's International Realty, Allyson leads a collective of like-minded real estate professionals united by a single mission: delivering results for buyers and sellers through passion and perseverance.

Passion + Perseverance = Results

Read Less

Read MoreRead Less
  • Agent Designations
    • Accredited Buyer Representative
    • Graduate, REALTOR® Institute
    • Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker
    • Certified Relocation Specialist
    • Waterfront Property Specialist
  • Awards
    • 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023,2024 #1 Team Old Lyme office for dollar volume
    • 2020, 2022, 2023,2024 #1 Team Old Lyme office for units sold
    • 2019, 2020 Platinum Award Winner William Pitt Sotheby's
    • 2016,2017, 2018, 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024 Gold Award Winner William Pitt Sotheby's
    • 2014 Silver Award Winner William Pitt Sotheby's
    • 2013 Bronze Award Winner William Pitt Sotheby's
    • #1 Producing Agent in Dollar Volume, Old Lyme Brokerage, 2017 2020
    • #2 Producing Agent in Dollar Volume, Old Lyme Brokerage,2017, 2019
    • Top 10 Agent for Units Sold 2019 William Pitt Award Winner
    • Five Star Real Estate Agent 2011-2024 (15 years)
  • Interests
    • Golfing
    • Biking
    • Kayaking

My Listings

41-1 Whippoorwill Road
Old Lyme, CT $1,799,000

41-1 Whippoorwill Road

Old Lyme, CT

$1,799,000
  • 4 Beds
  • 3/1 Baths
  • 3,345 Sqft
3 Farm Meadow Road
East Lyme, CT $155,000

3 Farm Meadow Road

East Lyme, CT

$155,000
  • 1.66 Acres
5 Farm Meadow Road
East Lyme, CT $155,000

5 Farm Meadow Road

East Lyme, CT

$155,000
  • 1.73 Acres
55 Bogel Road
East Haddam, CT $944,000

55 Bogel Road

East Haddam, CT

$944,000
  • 3 Beds
  • 1/1 Baths
  • 2,068 Sqft

My Sales

2 Old Stone Post Road
Lyme, CT $2,000,000
SOLD

2 Old Stone Post Road

Lyme, CT

$2,000,000
  • 4 Beds
  • 5/1 Baths
  • 4,695 Sqft
15 Sea Lane
Old Lyme, CT $1,680,000
SOLD

15 Sea Lane

Old Lyme, CT

$1,680,000
  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 1,809 Sqft
435 Hamburg Road
Lyme, CT $1,597,500
SOLD

435 Hamburg Road

Lyme, CT

$1,597,500
  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 5,100 Sqft
20 Ferry Road
Old Lyme, CT $1,495,000
SOLD

20 Ferry Road

Old Lyme, CT

$1,495,000
  • 4 Beds
  • 4/1 Baths
  • 4,090 Sqft

Additional Communities

Click to view listings available

Additional Communities

Click to view listings available
+-